I hope you guys enjoy my new background for product reviews! Anyways the other day I was at Target looking around and as I walked towards where Milani used to be, I saw NYX!!
I was like OMG wow! BUTTTT..to my disappointment they only carried a few things. However..my favorite eyeliner was there and I needed a new one.
I purchased my first one back in March and it has lasted me til September. I wear thick liner almost on a daily basis too. (hooded lids, liner doesn't show up too well)
When it dries, it's not completely matte, has a little shine/gloss to it. I love it and don't find it to move around. At both Ulta and Target I bought this for $5.99
doesn't budge but not waterproof
1 bottle lasts long
CONS: none that I can think of